Theater Review
Dead Outlaw, a delightfully deadpan new musical at the Minetta Lane Theater in Greenwich Village is based on a bizarre, but true story of an inept cowboy bandit in the early 1900s who was gunned down in a shoot-out with police. Due to some weird circumstances, his body was embalmed and went through some unusual adventures as a side-show attraction in various carnivals and amusement parks (“Step right up an see an actual HUMAN MUMMY!! Just a nickel!”) before being discovered by a technician on location for an episode of The Six Million Dollar Man in 1976. No kidding, this really happened.
Elmer McCurdy, was born in 1880, the son of a teenage unwed mom and was raised by his aunt and uncle in rural Maine. After a troubled youth he turned to drinking and rode the rails seeking work. At one point he served in the army under Douglas MacArthur where he had some rudimentary explosives training, which he later put to use when he formed a gang to rob banks and trains. Unfortunately for him, he wasn’t much good at it and after a number of bungled robberies, was killed when cornered by the law. Although not successful in life, McCurdy achieved notoriety in death and continued his drifting from town to town as his mummified corpse entertained thousands in several traveling road shows until it was finally retired 65 years after he died.
The show was conceived by David Yazbek, who was intrigued by this story for years, until he was able to find the right approach for bringing it to life. The book was by Itamar Moses and the director was David Cromer, both of whom collaborated with Yazbek on The Band’s Visit, winner of 10 Tony Awards including Best Musical. Dead Outlaw, with its equally ingenious and quirky story and outstanding music, as well as uniformly rave reviews, could very well follow in its “older brother’s” footsteps.
Music and lyrics were by Yazbek and Erik Della Penna. The music was inventive, with a unique cowboy rock twist, thanks in part to Della Penna who also plays guitar, lap steel guitar and banjo as well as sings in the band (which is on stage front and center for the entire show). We’ve been enjoying Della Penna’s music with our favorite band Hazmat Modine for years and his contributions to Dead Outlaw are both easy to discern and fun to hear.
Satirical lyrics were delivered with understated whimsy (e.g., in the songs “There’s Something About a Mummy!” and “Look at Me Dead”) and enhanced a finely sung and spoken narration by Jeb Brown that explored McCurdy’s life and “life” after death. Andrew Durand’s (Spring Awakening) portrayals of the living and embalmed McCurdy were entertaining and equally riveting. It can’t be easy to remain upright and motionless as his cadaver is schlepped around for half the show.
The supporting cast was uniformly solid and smoothly pulled off this truth is stranger-than-fiction Wild Bill Hickok farce. Of particular note, was the zany crooning of Thom Sesma, playing one of the two doctors performing separate autopsies on McCurdy’s corpse, and breaking into a Frank Sinatra style ballad about his results. As was Julia Knitel playing McCurdy’s one-time fiancé before he splits to begin his life of crime and years later, as she’s called upon to identify his long-dead corpse and serenades us as she tenderly laments he’d always been “A Stranger.”
Services to celebrate the Dead Mummy are scheduled at the Minetta Lane Theater for the next three weeks with final internment on April 7… unless of course, the body is exhumed and shipped uptown on the A Train for yet another Broadway revival!
The Sherman Holmes Project: The Richmond Sessions
Just What the Doctor Ordered
My friend and State of Virginia Folklorist, Jon Lohman surprised me recently with a copy of a new CD he’s produced entitled, The Sherman Holmes Project: The Richmond Sessions. Devoted followers of Opinion8ed2 will recognize Jon as the multi-talented force behind Jonny and the Jambusters and organizer/producer of the Crooked Road series. On first listen I realized it was something special… yet another exciting musical collaboration deserving of a review on these pages. (more…)
Share this:
Tags: Charlottesville, David Van Deventer, Ingramettes, Joan Osborne, Just what the doctor ordered, Rob Ickes, Sammy Shelor, Sherman Holmes, The Holmes Brothers, The Richmond Sessions, The Sherman Holmes Project, Virginia Folklife Mentorship Program